Comments
MIDTERMS - If Democrats want to win back Congress—and the White House—they need to do more than energize the base. They need to reconnect with the American middle. We’re living through a political era dominated by turnout wars and ideological purity tests, but the truth is simpler and more enduring: lasting power is won at the center.
Right now, the Democratic Party is rudderless. It’s unpopular, adrift, and bleeding support from moderates, independents, and working-class voters. If it wants to course-correct, it has to stop chasing online applause and return to being the party that delivers for everyday Americans. If it doesn’t, Elon Musk—or someone like him—is going to step into the vacuum and turn disillusionment into disruption.
A Brief Reminder: Realignment Is Inevitable
American politics has always evolved through periods of realignment—moments when coalitions shift, party identities transform, and the ground beneath our feet moves. The GOP was born in the 1850s as an anti-slavery movement. FDR’s New Deal reshaped the Democratic Party into a coalition of laborers, immigrants, and the economically marginalized. Then came the Civil Rights era, which splintered that coalition. By the 1980s, Reagan had rebranded the GOP around free markets and family values.
We’re in the midst of another realignment now—but Democrats seem paralyzed by it. The party that once stood for working families, shared prosperity, and inclusion now sounds like it’s speaking in code to university faculty lounges. Instead of offering a big-picture agenda, Democrats deliver piecemeal slogans and culture war soundbites. People notice—and they’re walking away.
The Musk Mirage
Enter Elon Musk. A billionaire with a Twitter addiction and a growing disdain for both parties, Musk is toying with the idea of backing—or launching—a third party. His pitch is seductive to many: a mix of anti-wokeness, free speech absolutism, and techno-futurism wrapped in libertarian cool.
But here’s the truth: third parties don’t win in America. They don’t even come close. The Electoral College, our voting system, and ballot access laws make sure of that. Musk would end up where Ross Perot, Ralph Nader, Jill Stein, and Howard Schultz did: on the sidelines.
More importantly, Musk himself is toxic. For all his fans in tech and finance circles, he’s wildly polarizing. His public behavior, conspiracy-laced posts, and tolerance for extremists have alienated huge swaths of the electorate—especially women, young people, and voters of color.
The danger isn’t that Musk will win. It’s that he fills the void Democrats are leaving wide open. He’s a symptom of the party’s drift, not the cure for it. But if Democrats don’t act soon, he—or someone like him—will define the new political center. And that’s a risk Democrats can’t afford.
The Real Messaging Problem: We’re Losing the Trust Game
Even if Democrats pivot back to practical problem-solving, they’re up against a communication landscape wired for outrage. Social media doesn’t reward nuance or substance—it rewards volume and venom. The loudest, angriest voices dominate. Outrage sells. Trust... not so much.
That’s a big problem for Democrats, whose strength has always been ideas, policy, and governance. But too often, they sound like they’re reading from a policy memo rather than connecting with real people. While Republicans rebel, Democrats recite.
In this environment, the most radical thing Democrats can do is be real. Speak plainly. Show some humility. Sound like they’ve actually stepped outside the Beltway and felt the frustration most Americans feel.
Because at the end of the day, Americans aren’t just tired of partisanship—they’re tired of phoniness. They don’t want lectures or culture war crusades. They want someone to talk about the cost of gas, the chaos at the border, the school that doesn’t feel safe, or the job they might lose next month.
It’s time for Democrats to elevate different voices—nurses, veterans, teachers, parents, mayors. People who look and sound like the country. People who’ve lived the stakes. Not just the next TikTok-savvy political operative in a blazer.
In a chaotic media world, authenticity is Democrats’ secret weapon. It just happens to be the one they use the least.
Democrats Need Fighters Who Win in the Middle
Winning the White House—and building a durable congressional majority—won’t come from going louder or further left. It’ll come from leaders who can meet voters where they are: in the middle. Leaders who can flip counties, not just hashtags.
That’s why people like Jon Tester, Josh Shapiro, Wes Moore, Andy Beshear, and Abigail Spanberger are the real future of the party. They don’t just poll well—they win in places where Democrats usually don’t. And they don’t win by pretending to be something they’re not. They win by being practical, plainspoken, and unafraid to take on their own side.
Compare that with some of the most visible figures on the left—folks who energize the base but alienate the swing voters needed to actually govern. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez is a talented communicator and a smart policymaker. But she’s never had to win over a Republican voter.
She’s never had to campaign in a 50/50 district. Her brand of politics just doesn’t translate in purple states or working-class towns.
This isn’t about purity tests—it’s about coalitions. Democrats win big when they run people who can speak across divides. When they forget that, they lose winnable races in Georgia, Michigan, and Wisconsin. And they give away the heartland without a fight.
Meet the Moment—or Miss It
Democrats are standing at a fork in the road. They can either keep drifting—disconnected from working-class anxieties and addicted to the latest activist buzzword—or they can get back to being the party of practical solutions, broad coalitions, and real economic fairness.
Elon Musk’s political dabbling is a warning shot. It tells us that a huge swath of Americans are still looking for something that feels grounded, trustworthy, and unifying. If Democrats don’t fill that space, someone else will—and it won’t end well.
America doesn’t need a third party. It needs a better version of the first one.
(John Shallman is an award-winning political media consultant and crisis management expert and President of Shallman Communications in Los Angeles. Mr. Shallman is the author of the national best-selling book, Return from Siberia. www.shallmancommunications.com)
