California Ranks Among 10 Most Dangerous U.S. States for Students Commuting by School Bus

June 20 2025

Written by CityWatch.

SCHOOL BUS - A new study reveals that California has the third highest school bus crash rates in the U.S.

The research by Nevada-based personal injury lawyers H&P Law analyzed school bus crash data between 2019 and 2023, from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). The average annual crashes were compared to the number of K-12 students transported to identify the top 10 states where commuting by school bus poses the highest risk for students.

California comes in third with an average school bus crash rate of 529.2 per 100,000 students transported, which is 87% above the national average of 282.7. With 1,100,000 K-12 students transporting daily, the Golden State recorded its lowest number of crashes (5,203) in 2019 and its highest (6,471) in 2021.

Looking at the study, a spokesperson at H&P Law commented:

"The data reveals that California reported the third highest school bus crash rates in the U.S.

"High population density, challenging traffic conditions, and longer average commuting distances contribute to these concerning statistics. In some cases, aging bus fleets and infrastructure challenges may further compound the problem.

"While school buses remain one of the safest modes of transportation for students overall, these findings call for increased safety measures in high-risk states. School districts are urged to implement enhanced driver training programs, consider route optimization, and maintain rigorous vehicle maintenance schedules."

Table of Extended Results:

The study was conducted by H&P Law, an experienced personal injury law firm dedicated to protecting clients' rights and maximizing claim value.

Methodology

The research analyzed school bus crash data between 2019 and 2023, from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). The average annual crashes were compared to the number of K-12 students transported to identify the top 10 states where commuting by school bus poses the highest risk for students.

Data Sources