#  Someone Tell the US Supreme Court: Housing Is a Human Right!

     Details    John Raphling   ![logo](https://mail.citywatchla.com//templates/ja_teline_v/images/logo.png)         July 18 2024      [  ![](https://mail.citywatchla.com/images/stories/July-2024/058b.jpg#joomlaImage://local-images/stories/July-2024/058b.jpg?width=1124&height=632)    ](https://mail.citywatchla.com/important-reads/29232-someone-tell-the-us-supreme-court-housing-is-a-human-right)

  [IMPORTANT READS](https://mail.citywatchla.com/important-reads)   - [  Previous Article **Targeting Corporate Landlords, Biden to Unveil National Rent Control Plan** ](https://mail.citywatchla.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=29234:targeting-corporate-landlords-biden-to-unveil-national-rent-control-plan&catid=9)
- [  Next Article **California Gambling Laws: An Overview of State Regulations** ](https://mail.citywatchla.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=29228:california-gambling-laws-an-overview-of-state-regulations&catid=9)

  ###### Typography

- [](# "Smaller Font")  ****Smaller** **Small** **Medium** **Big** **Bigger****  [](# "Bigger Font")
- [](# "Previous Font Style")  ****Default** **Helvetica** **Segoe** **Georgia** **Times****  [](# "Next Font Style")

- [ Reading Mode](# "Reading Mode")

> <a class="a2a_button_facebook"></a><a class="a2a_button_twitter"></a><a class="a2a_button_email"></a><a class="a2a_button_print"></a>[](https://www.addtoany.com/share)
>
>  [Comments](#disqus_thread)

 HOUSING CRISIS - The United States Supreme Court decision last month in [Grants Pass v. Johnson ](https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/23pdf/23-175_19m2.pdf)gives local governments across the country the authority to ticket, arrest, and punish unhoused people for simply existing in public spaces. The ruling undermines the right to adequate housing in the U.S.; it is also profoundly cruel and risks an increase in ineffective criminalization.

In its ruling, the court overturned decisions by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit in this case and in [Martin v. Boise](https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2018/09/04/15-35845.pdf), which limited punishment if there was no other place for a person legally to go or if there was no shelter available. The court said that criminalizing a person for their unhoused status does not violate the prohibition on “cruel and unusual punishments” in the Eighth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.

Criminalization causes suffering, but does nothing to house people.

The Supreme Court had [previously held](https://www.oyez.org/cases/1961/554#:~:text=6%E2%80%932%20decision%20for%20Robinson&text=In%20a%206%2D2%20decision,the%20Eighth%20and%20Fourteenth%20Amendments.) that authorities may not punish a person based solely on their status, as opposed to their conduct. The Grants Pass majority did not explicitly overrule that precedent, but said the Eighth Amendment only applies to the form of punishment—not the outlawed conduct or status—and that state governments may choose to criminalize whatever they want without violating the Constitution. This ruling opens the door to further punishment of poverty and other statuses.

This decision gives local and state governments a green light to enact and enforce laws banning unhoused people from public spaces, regardless of whether adequate housing or shelter is available to them. States across the country, including [Georgia](https://www.wabe.org/georgia-lawmakers-localities-must-apply-homeless-camp-bans/), [Texas](https://legiscan.com/TX/text/HB1925/2021), [Florida](https://eu.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2024/03/21/florida-camping-ban-homeless-public-spaces/73048034007/), and [others](https://stateline.org/2022/04/08/homeless-camping-bans-are-spreading-this-group-shaped-the-bills/), have already passed such laws. A [recent study](https://homelesslaw.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/HOUSING-NOT-HANDCUFFS-2019-FINAL.pdf) found that the majority of cities examined already had such laws in place.

In Los Angeles, previously limited by the Ninth Circuit precedent, city councilmembers have already [begun](https://x.com/jacobwooch/status/1806877789804728748) to explore options to further criminalize unhoused people in light of the Supreme Court decision. Other jurisdictions will likely race to take similar steps, not wanting to be the only areas in their region where unhoused people can safely stay.

Criminalization is not, as the majority opinion claims, a legitimate tool to combat houselessness as it subjects people to cruel treatment and arbitrary arrest, punishing them for simply existing in public space because they lack housing. Criminalization is also proven to be [ineffective](http://www.direitoamoradia.fau.usp.br/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/searchingoutsolutions_homelessness.pdf). It forces unhoused people to hide from view, separating them from helpful services. Criminalization causes suffering, but does nothing to [house people](https://homelesslaw.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/HOUSING-NOT-HANDCUFFS-2019-FINAL.pdf). This ruling allows authorities to ignore real solutions, especially providing and preserving affordable housing, because they can simply chase unhoused people away with the threat of criminal enforcement.

*(John Raphling is a senior researcher on criminal justice for the U.S. program at Human Rights Watch. This article was published in CommonDreams.org.)*

  - [  Previous Article **Targeting Corporate Landlords, Biden to Unveil National Rent Control Plan** ](https://mail.citywatchla.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=29234:targeting-corporate-landlords-biden-to-unveil-national-rent-control-plan&catid=9)
- [  Next Article **California Gambling Laws: An Overview of State Regulations** ](https://mail.citywatchla.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=29228:california-gambling-laws-an-overview-of-state-regulations&catid=9)
<div data-id="1" 
	class="eb-inst eb-hide eb-emailform eb-1 eboxContentLocker"
	data-options='{"trigger":"onPageLoad","trigger_selector":"","delay":3000,"early_trigger":true,"scroll_depth":"percentage","scroll_depth_value":80,"firing_frequency":1,"reverse_scroll_close":true,"threshold":0,"close_out_viewport":false,"exit_timer":1000,"idle_time":10000,"close_on_esc":false,"animation_open":"slideInDown","animation_close":"fadeOutDown","animation_duration":400,"disable_page_scroll":true,"test_mode":false,"debug":false,"ga_tracking":true,"ga_tracking_id":"G-P16BQ7X1SW","ga_tracking_event_category":"EngageBox","ga_tracking_event_label":"Box #1 - Global Email Signup Form","auto_focus":false}'
	data-type='popup'
	>

	<button type="button" data-ebox-cmd="close" class="eb-close placement-outside" aria-label="Close">
	<img alt="close popup button" />
	<span aria-hidden="true">&times;</span>
</button>
	<div class="eb-dialog eb-formVer" role="dialog" aria-modal="true" id="dialog1" aria-label="dialog1">
		
		<button type="button" data-ebox-cmd="close" class="eb-close placement-inside" aria-label="Close">
	<img alt="close popup button" />
	<span aria-hidden="true">&times;</span>
</button>	
		<div class="eb-container">
						<div class="eb-content">
				
<form action="https://citywatchla.us2.list-manage.com/subscribe/post?u=34d69f33624fd058ee9b56516&amp;id=4bfa422f51&amp;f_id=00d6c2e1f0" class="eb" method="post" id="mcform-1" name="mcform-1" target="_blank">
			<div class="eb-form-header"><p><img src="/images/2023/06/be-a-city-watcher.png" alt="be a city watcher" width="350" height="97" loading="lazy" data-path="local-images:/2023/06/be-a-city-watcher.png"></p>
<p>Sign up to receive our special e-news blasts on Monday and Thursday evenings!</p></div>
	
					<div class="eb-field-row">

			
			
			
			<input class="eb-input" type="email" name="EMAIL"  placeholder="Email address"  id="EMAIL" value="" required>

			
		</div>
										
	<div class="eb-footer">
    	<button class="eb-btn" type="submit" name="subscribe" style="background-color:rgba(93, 183, 93, 1);color:rgba(255, 255, 255, 1)">
    		Sign up    	</button>
    </div>
</form>			</div>
		</div>
	</div>	
</div>
<div data-id="3" 
	class="eb-inst eb-hide eb-yesno eb-3 "
	data-options='{"trigger":"onScrollDepth","trigger_selector":"","delay":0,"early_trigger":false,"scroll_depth":"percentage","scroll_depth_value":80,"firing_frequency":2,"reverse_scroll_close":false,"threshold":0,"close_out_viewport":false,"exit_timer":1000,"idle_time":1000,"close_on_esc":false,"animation_open":"fadeInUp","animation_close":"fadeOut","animation_duration":300,"disable_page_scroll":false,"test_mode":false,"debug":false,"ga_tracking":true,"ga_tracking_id":"G-P16BQ7X1SW","ga_tracking_event_category":"EngageBox","ga_tracking_event_label":"Box #3 - Yes \/ No Donation Popup Box","auto_focus":false}'
	data-type='popup'
	>

	<button type="button" data-ebox-cmd="close" class="eb-close placement-outside" aria-label="Close">
	<img alt="close popup button" />
	<span aria-hidden="true">&times;</span>
</button>
	<div class="eb-dialog " role="dialog" aria-modal="true" id="dialog3" aria-label="dialog3">
		
		<button type="button" data-ebox-cmd="close" class="eb-close placement-inside" aria-label="Close">
	<img alt="close popup button" />
	<span aria-hidden="true">&times;</span>
</button>	
		<div class="eb-container">
						<div class="eb-content">
				
<div class="ebox-yes-no">
	<div class="ebox-yn-text">
		
		
		<div class="ebox-yn-headline" style="font-size:22px;color:#888888">
			<p>If you only give once a month, would you consider giving to CityWatch?</p>
<p>Your support fuels our mission to promote and facilitate civic engagement and neighborhood empowerment, and to hold area government and its politicians accountable.</p>
<p>Would you like to help? Even if you can only give $5, it will make a difference.</p>		</div>
			</div>
	
	<div class="ebox-ys-buttons" style="font-size: 16px;">
		
<a
					data-ebox-prevent="0"
		data-ebox-cmd="close"
				target="_self"
		href="https://www.citywatchla.com/donate"
		rel="noopener"
	
	
	
	
	class="ebox-ys-btn"
	style="background-color:#2ec664;color:#ffffff;min-width:100px">
	Yes
	</a>
<a
	
	
			data-ebox-cmd="close"
		href="#"
	
	
	class="ebox-ys-btn"
	style="background-color:#ef2345;color:#ffffff;min-width:100px">
	Not Right Now
	</a>	</div>

	</div>			</div>
		</div>
	</div>	
</div>